HQAM STEHT Für
 

Qualität

Enterpreneuership

Performance

Nachhaltigkeit

ALL EARNINGS ARE NOT CREATED EQUAL

Fundamentals are back in focus

Recently, a note from Morgan Stanley, which found that the gap between reported earnings and cash flow of US companies is the widest in 25 years1, has caught our attention, as it touches upon the concept of earnings quality, which has always been one of the cornerstones of our investment approach. Early this year we saw junk stocks rallying again on no fundamental ground, as short-covering and expectations for
long-awaited end of tightening cycle provided a boost to low quality companies. However, experience of late 2021-2022 clearly showed that such gains are hardly sustainable over the long run, which we focus on.

As we exit the era of zero interest-rate policy, in which even the weakest companies could prosper, investors urge companies to focus more on profitability, cash flow generation and shareholders’ reward, rather than chasing growth at all costs. As investors become more selective and scrutinize the true earnings power of their holdings, earnings quality analysis is becoming more important to identify long-term investment opportunities. Instead of relying solely on EPS figures, cash flow analysis is a good complementary tool to assess the quality of earnings. Indeed, across all major markets, not only US, cash conversion ratio – the ratio of operating cash flow to EBITDA – has fallen recently from post-pandemic peak, as shown on Fig. 1.

Figure 1: Cash conversion in US, Europe, Switzerland, Japan (based on current index constituents)

Source: Hérens Quality AM,

Cash flow matters
When earnings remain robust, but cash flows deteriorate, analysts should begin to raise questions. Over the long term, we notice that the market particularly rewards those companies that deliver earnings growth that is backed up by ample cash flows. As shown in Fig. 2, over the last 5 years, companies that have delivered above-average EPS growth and operating cash flow growth have also seen substantially higher price returns, as compared to those companies that have outperformed only on EPS growth, with cash flows lagging behind.

Figure 2: Annualized price return (March 2018-March 2023) in relation to EPS and cash flow growth

Source: Hérens Quality AM, Refinitiv

Adjustments jungle

Choosing the best metrics to evaluate business performance may sometimes be a challenge for analysts. It is quite common for companies to adjust their reported earnings for analysts’ convenience, but it is always a good idea to question such adjustments, as they may sometimes present a more favorable picture than reality. In fact, the SEC has recently been clashing with some companies, which take adjustments too far.

Among most common adjustments is adding back acquisition-related amortization expenses, which makes total sense, but when the said acquisition was dilutive, carried a sky-high multiple, did not deliver on promised synergies and eventually resulted in goodwill write-downs – value is destroyed, and if it is not a one-time mistake, questions should be raised about executives’ capital management abilities.

Another common adjustment is stock-based compensation, which is an important tool to motivate employees, more commonly in US. As a non-cash expense, certainly companies prefer to adjust their earnings for stock-based compensation, but there is no free lunch. Shareholders should ask, if, and to which extent, they are being diluted and whether the amount of compensation is reasonable and proportional to business growth.

Plausibility check is especially required when the gap between reported and adjusted earnings is quite high. For example, Stryker, a medical device manufacturer, usually reports adjusted profits 50-70% higher that of statutory net income. Company’s adjustments include, among other things, regular restructuring charges (if they occur each year, it begs to ask whether something is wrong with the business), medical device regulations costs (such as updating product labeling to comply with regulations – something we would think is a normal operating expense for a medical company) and recall-related adjustments (when they happen each year, one should dig deeper into quality control practices as they are essential for a medical company to succeed). While Stryker’s adjusted earnings have been on an upward trend recently, cash flow from operations and free cash flow have essentially remained flat over the last 5 years. Increasingly questionable earnings quality was one of the reasons we decided to part with the Company.

Figure 3: Stryker Corporation earnings and cash flow figures

Source: Hérens Quality AM, Stryker Corporation

Earnings quality within quality investing framework

To make sure companies in our portfolios possess strong and sustainable earnings power, each company that we consider as a buy candidate is subject to earnings quality analysis. For this purpose, we have a special earnings quality score that alerts us of any red flags that require scrutiny. The score considers aspects, such as cash conversion, plausibility of changes in balance sheet items in relation to sales and expense growth, efficiency metrics, accruals, profitability ratios, etc. The final assessment is a net score: the number of praise-worthy metrics is decreased by the number of red flags, and the maximum is 25 (though we currently do not see a Company with such high quality of earnings across our investment universes). According to our methodology, earnings quality is the lowest in Japan and the highest in US, although in all markets we manage to find decent companies to invest in, as shown by better scores across quality funds.

Figure 4: Earnings quality scores of HQAM quality funds, compared to the market

Source: Hérens Quality AM, Refinitiv

As investors are moving back to basics, seeking a fine balance between long-term growth, solid profitability and cash generation, we believe this trend plays well for quality companies, and premium that they command for sustainability of their earnings could only widen.

References:

  1. Bloomberg (2023). Corporate America’s Earnings Quality Is the Worst in Three Decades, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-01/corporate-america-s-earnings-quality-is-worst-in-three-decades
  2. Wall Street Journal (2023). SEC Expected to Raise More Questions About How Firms Calculate Non-GAAP Measures, https://www.wsj.com/articles/sec-expected-to-raise-more-questions-about-how-firms-calculate-non-gaap-measures-4ab42b9

ADVERTISEMENT

This document has been prepared solely for information and advertising purposes and does not constitute a solicitation offer or recommendation to buy or sell any investment product or to engage in any other transactions.

Scroll to Top

DISCLAIMER

 «I have read and understood the aforementioned provisions and agree to the contents».

 

Non-Binding

The information published on this website does not constitute a recommendation, an offer, or a solicitation to buy or sell investment instruments, to engage in transactions or to enter into any type of legal transaction. The published information and expressions of opinions are made available by Hérens Quality Asset Management AG exclusively for personal use and for informational and advertising purposes only; they may be altered at any time and without prior notice. For further information, please consult the Basic Information Sheet (BIS), the prospectus, or other relevant documents under foreign law that are equivalent to the Basic Information Sheet (such as Key Information Documents/KIDs), which can be downloaded from www.hqam.ch. Hérens Quality Asset Management AG does not make any warranty (neither expressly nor implicitly) about the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the published information and expressions of opinion. The information on this website does not represent an aid for making decisions on commercial, legal, tax or other advisory issues, nor may any investment or other decisions be taken based solely on this information. Advice from a qualified expert is recommended.

Limitation of Liability

Hérens Quality Asset Management AG disclaims all liability whatsoever for losses or damages of any type – whether direct, indirect, or consequential damages – that may result based on the use of or access to this website or based on links to websites of third parties. Furthermore, Hérens Quality Asset Management AG disclaims all liability for manipulations by unauthorized third parties of the EDP system of the Internet user. In this regard, Hérens Quality Asset Management AG expressly refers to the danger of viruses and the possibility of targeted attacks by hackers. For purposes of combating viruses, the use of current browser versions as well as the installation of anti-virus software that is continuously updated is recommended. Internet users should basically refrain from opening emails of unknown original and unexpected attachments to an email.

Links

Certain links on this website lead to websites of third parties. These websites are completely beyond the control of Hérens Quality Asset Management AG, which is why Hérens Quality Asset Management AG disclaims all liability for the accuracy, completeness and lawfulness of the content of such websites as well as for any offers and services that may be contained therein.

Local Legal Restrictions

The website of Hérens Quality Asset Management AG is not intended for persons who are subject to a legal system that prohibits the publication or accessing of this website (based on the nationality of the person in question, his/her place of residence or other reasons). Persons who are subject to such restrictions are prohibited from accessing the website of Hérens Quality Asset Management AG.

Use of This Website

The entire content of this website is protected by copyright law. It is permissible to save or print out individual pages for personal or non-commercial use. The complete or partial reproduction, transmission (electronically or otherwise), modification, linking to or use of the website of Hérens Quality Asset Management AG for public or commercial purposes is prohibited in the absence of the prior written consent of Hérens Quality Asset Management AG.